Assume a situation when some guests show up at your door, and you need to serve dinner with some signature meat dishes. But, unfortunately, you have run out of poultry seasoning, which is an essential ingredient in signature meat dishes. 

Thus, in such instances, you will have to be aware of the substitutes that you can use in place of this condiment. So, accordingly, the best replacements for poultry seasoning would be:

  • The blend of four basic herbs (Rosemary, thyme, marjoram, sage)
  • Italian seasoning
  • Herbes de Provence
  • Zaatar
  • Garlic
  • Salt and Pepper

So, scroll down to learn how these substitutes will help to bring out the flavor of poultry seasoning without worrying you.

Best Substitutes For Poultry Seasoning

The best feeling will be when you are able to manage the things in your kitchen you already have without running to the store. And, that is our sole intention of bringing this article- to avoid you from being panicked when you are dried up without poultry seasoning in your kitchen.

Best Substitutes For Poultry Seasoning - SpiceRally

The substitutes that we discuss through this article will not ruin your meat or whatever dish you hope to make that calls for poultry seasoning. What you should remember is about the intention of using a “substitute”. Apparently, a substitute will be a closer match to the original product that will have a similar taste. But it will not have the exact flavor that the actual ingredient would provide. Therefore, we should be careful when choosing a replacement to match it closely with the taste and aroma of the original element. 

Check out these best poultry seasoning substitutes and match them with your dishes whenever your seasoning jar runs empty!

01 – The Blend Of Four Basic Herbs: Thyme, Rosemary, Sage, And Marjoram

You already know that poultry seasoning is typically heavy on herbs, and most of it contains thyme, rosemary, sage, and marjoram. So, if you do not have the seasoning in your spice rack, but if you are available with these four herbs, then you’ll win! 

Poultry seasoning generally does not count on exotic ingredients. But, the flavor of it relies a lot on sage. So, if you already have sage and other three types of herbs with you, try mixing a little amount of salt, black pepper, and even garlic and ginger powder if you like. Now you can use this mixture as one of the best substitutes for poultry seasoning with your chicken, turkey, or any dish you wish to prepare.

If you are curious about finding substitutes when cooking, the ultimate list of Worcestershire sauce substitutes will amaze you! Just tap here and check out the best Worcestershre sauce replacement and pick your favorite.

02 – Italian Seasoning

Italian seasoning would be the next best choice of substitute for poultry seasoning. It is assembled of herbs that are used frequently in Italian cooking, such as oregano, thyme, rosemary, and marjoram. In fact, the ingredients are very comparable to those used in poultry seasoning, making it an ideal replacement if you don’t have the actual element with you.

However, since Italian seasoning typically does not contain sage and spices, the taste will have slight differences. But, still, it will make a great substitute as it contains the herbs.

03 – Herbes de Provence

Originated in France, Herbes de Provence is another worthy replacement for poultry seasoning. The list of ingredients in Herbes de Provence may differ from the traditional American poultry seasoning, but it will clearly not affect much with the taste. The classic Herbes de Provence recipe often includes ingredients like thyme, rosemary, marjoram, oregano, savory and lavender.

So, you see that the majority of it contains the essential herbs that go into the poultry seasoning. But, it generally does not have sage. And on the other hand, it includes lavender which you might not expect but could necessarily work well with meat.

In a nutshell, Herbes de Provence is an excellent substitute in place of poultry seasoning. But, it would be best if you add sage so that you could get the original poultry seasoning taste.

04 – Zaatar

Zaatar is a mix of multiple culinary herbs and spices extensively used in Middle Eastern cuisine. It is generally a blend of dried thyme, oregano, marjoram, toasted sesame seeds, and sumac. Some Zaatar recipes even contain dried orange zest, salt, dried dill, and the wild herb za’atar.

So, if you have this in your spice rack, it will undoubtedly make another fantastic substitute for poultry seasoning since it contains the basic herbs. It gives a herbal, nutty, woodsy all-round flavor that is closely related to poultry seasoning.

Poultry seasoning substitutes are always better when you don’t have the actual product to flavor your dishes. But, how do you like it to make your own homemade poultry seasoning? Just tap here for a great and easy homemade poultry seasoning recipe.

05 – Garlic

You might be wondering if a single spice could even come closer to the original flavor of a complete seasoning. The answer to that is that garlic is a pungent, intense, and powerful spice with overwhelming flavoring properties. 

So, if you have a container of garlic powder in your spice rack, try mixing it with one or two herbs that are available to you at the moment. You may not have all the herbs, but one or two of them could go a long way when mixed with garlic powder and a bit of salt and pepper. Even if you don’t have any herbs, garlic mixed with salt and pepper (which you would hardly run out of stock) will give a great taste to your meat dishes by helping to substitute poultry seasoning.

06 – Salt and Pepper

Last but not least, how can we ignore the best and most popular seasoning in the world? If you do not have anything else that we discussed throughout this article, but still, if you have salt and pepper, then they will come to your rescue!

Assume that you have garlic powder, ginger powder, and other spices, even there isn’t any herb. Then, you can endeavor to mix and match the spices with salt and pepper to make a seasoning blend that could go with your meat recipe. The best thing is that salt and pepper are versatile flavorings that pairs with any herb or other spice. Hence, whatever you’ve got in your spice cabinet, you can combine them with these two.

Just like the above would substitute poultry seasoning, did you know that Garam Masala also could be substituted by several other flavorings? For an ultimate Garam Masala substitute guide, click here!

So, Did You Notice That Substituting Poultry Seasoning Is Real Simple?

These six best substitutes for poultry seasoning that we discussed through this feature will open up a path to think you out of the box. In fact, you discovered that you could use the ingredients that are easily found in your kitchen if you run out of poultry seasoning. 

All you need is a little bit of creative sense, and voila, you will never panic about not having the actual ingredient to flavor the dishes you make!

Write A Comment