We all know that gyro seasoning is a great addition when you need to come up with flavorful gyro meat. So, we will share the best gyro seasoning substitutes you can use whenever the original blend is not around.

Gyro seasoning has a vivid flavor profile featuring many potent spices and herbs. Thus, the best possible alternatives include:

  1. Greek Seasoning
  2. Mediterranean Seasoning Blends
  3. Homemade Gyro Seasoning
  4. Chili Powder + Dried Herbs
  5. Poultry Seasoning

So are you curious to know how these substitutes will work their best to give a close flavor? Then, continue reading!

The 5 Best Gyro Seasoning Substitutes

Gyro seasoning typically has a bold, earthy, spicy, deep flavor with a sound amount of heat. As a reminder, our topic leader generally contains ingredients like:

Gyro Seasoning And Its Ingredients - SpiceRally

This is, in fact, a unique blend of aromatics with only a few replacement options that could be used to bring out a similar flavor. Therefore, with comprehensive research, we came up with the following gyro seasoning substitutes.

01- Greek Seasoning

If you are looking for a readily available product that could mimic the taste of our topic leader, Greek seasoning can be one of your best picks! This is an all-purpose seasoning blend that shares a set of common ingredients such as:

  • Cinnamon
  • Garlic powder
  • Paprika
  • Dried herbs (oregano, thyme, parsley)
  • Salt

However, you will not get chili powder in traditional Greek seasoning. And it also contains additional ingredients like ground nutmeg and black pepper

Hence, if you prefer more heat, you can add a little bit of chili powder to balance out the flavor. You can also start with a small amount if you are uncertain about the taste but a replacement of a 1:1 ratio will work better.

02- Mediterranean Seasoning Blends

If you have any type of Mediterranean spice blend/seasoning at home, you win! Or else, if you observe the supermarket’s spice aisle, you can find many combinations labeled in several names like Mediterranean herb and salt blend, Mediterranean spice and herb mix, etc.

Many of these mixtures come together with similar ingredients to our topic leader, such as:

  • Ground cumin
  • Paprika
  • Garlic powder
  • Ground coriander seeds
  • Thyme 
  • Oregano
  • Salt

The real trick here is to read the list of ingredients well on the packaging and match it with the flavoring elements of the gyro seasoning

You can make little adjustments by adding chili powder for an extra punch of flavor. It is always better to begin with a small amount and then proceed since some Mediterranean seasoning blends contain additional spices like sumac.

03- Homemade Gyro Seasoning

If you expect to have the exact flavor of our topic leader to your gyros from an alternative, making your own batch of gyro seasoning at home is your best bet! In fact, it will offer similar taste elements just like the ones you buy from the store.

So, if you are interested in trying a simple gyro seasoning recipe, we have posted a step-by-step guide that you can prepare in under ten minutes. Click here!

04- Chili Powder + Dried Herbs

If you have chili powder and two or more types of dried herbs in hand, this combination can give you a very close flavor replication to gyro seasoning.

Most chili powders come as a blend of chili pepper powder, ground cumin, garlic powder, and salt. Therefore, you can mix in pinches of dried herbs like oregano, thyme, parsley, rosemary, savory, or whatever you have with chili powder. More herbs- the more taste you get!

You can use this combination as the same amount you use our subject leader. But if you think the flavor is not enough, you can increase the ingredients of the mixture respectively and build up the desired taste.

Part of the secret of success is to eat what you like and let the food fight it out inside.

Mark Twain

05- Poultry Seasoning

This option is one of the most easily accessible gyro seasoning substitutes. It has the capacity to complement the richness of the meat while sharing some common ingredients with our topic leader. And they are:

  • Paprika
  • Garlic powder
  • Ground coriander
  • Dried herbs (thyme, oregano, marjoram, rosemary)

In addition to these spices and herbs, most poultry seasoning versions could also contain ground nutmeg and black pepper. 

However, adding some chili powder will give a closer flavor approximation. Begin moderately and adjust the amount more or less based on your taste preference.

Winding Up With The Best Gyro Seasoning Substitutes…

As you see, Greek seasoning, Mediterranean seasoning blends, poultry seasoning, etc., are the best possibilities that will give a comparable flavor to the original blend. You can reap the best results with little adjustments without worrying about not having gyro seasoning around.

Related Topics

Write A Comment